Can you fail a thesis defense

revisions after dissertation defense

The only way you can fail your part is if you put in an extra effort in make an unintelligible presentation. I think that the whole process of defending a thesis means you have to trust that the committee members are more right than you and what they suggest is actually correct.

While my committee had high expectations from me, they asked very reasonable questions during my thesis defense. My adviser should never be allowed to supervise a PhD student ever again, famous name or no.

Then I worked my ass off for another semester, rewriting a couple of chapters and rebuilding my experimental infrastructure so it was capable of running the experiments I needed to do. It can just as well be that the democratic process unexpectedly for some tipped the balance. I wouldn't advise you to stick with if.

They did not give any indication they would not pass me during the pre-defense meeting, and let me do my presentation. The worst that can happen is that they will disagree with you, and you will learn something new.

My thoughts are that, in the interest of academic integrity, you should be able to ask your committee members for a reason for a change and defend your point of view.

How long is a masters thesis defense

More below. I went home, depressed, and came back a few days later and buckled down, studied more of the fundamentals for stuff in my thesis, boned up on some of the questions that my committee asked, came back 3 months later and did fine. So I have to second this comment upthread: It is unusual for someone to defend with encouragement from their advisor and committee and then be asked to do significant revisions. I think that the whole process of defending a thesis means you have to trust that the committee members are more right than you and what they suggest is actually correct. In my program most people had to do dissertation revisions before finishing. I'd spend a little time looking into departmental gossip. Be nice to your future self and work those extra months now. Turned down, hone, improve, apply again. But if it looks like it will be a huge amount of work and delay your life for yet another year, and if your dream career doesn't require the degree, it might be most prudent to walk away. Take a break until you can meet with your chair. Your advisor needs to be your champion right now. If it's reasonable and you can get them to be specific and you can see how to do it and there's a light at the end of the tunnel, then stick with it for another year or however long this shit goes. My point is: getting to know the gossip that eventually trickled through hurt my feelings back then, and 30 years later it still hurts when I think of it. I almost had to do it again before I got a copy of the department deadlines from the admin office.

Figure out what you need to do to pass, and better yet, what you need to do to pass in December.

Rated 10/10 based on 103 review
Download
5 Thesis Defense Myths: Your Committee is NOT Out to Get You